Hog or Fish--The Great Debate

Hey, Yo Big Wave clean your lens once in a while. Check That!
The hog or the fish that is the question. I don't know which board to use.  They are rated for similar conditions, but do different things. I just wanna make the right choice. I went with the Hog today 'cause it was so windy.

Too Bad you can't see 'cause these are some really nice rides. Bummer.